Showing posts with label stupid questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stupid questions. Show all posts

Sunday, July 21, 2013

Now you see me, now you don't. (Stupid Questions)


I took the boys, Mr F and Mr Bunches, to the swimming pool yesterday.  That in itself was not unusual and is only a lead-in to this post, because absolutely nothing remarkable occurred while we were on the way to swimming, while we were swimming, or on the way home from swimming.  In fact, the swimming thing is really irrelevant to the post, as the inception of this post could have come anywhere, or everywhere, but in this case, it happened at the pool, where I was, yesterday. Swimming.

Here's what happened while I was swimming: I was looking a bit at the way the water reflects off the pool and watching Mr Bunches swim all the way across the pool, which he can do now, and I thought to myself

Stupid Question #1: Why can't we see air?

I mean, all my life I've been told that the sky is blue because light bounces off of it, or refracts, or something, that in essence light is bouncing off the sky and we are seeing the blue light, the rest of it being absorbed by the sky, which, as I sat in the pool playing "Sea Turtle & Sloth" (that will require an explanation some other day) began to bug me more and more, in that the sky is made of air and so why can we see the sky when it's way up there, off in the distance, above the trees and above the Ace Hardware and above airplanes, but we can't see the sky when it's right down here on top of the pool?

And, for that matter, Stupid question #2 Why does the sky reflect all the same uniform shade of blue, instead of slightly different colors because the sky is made up of different atoms or molecules or something of air, and why would nitrogen reflect the same color of blue as oxygen?

 So I kept thinking about it, as I swam and played "Up!" with Mr F (not the movie; while we play lots of movies, those are mostly with Mr Bunches and mostly involve the scenes where two characters fight, like when the chef tries to kill Sebastian in The Little Mermaid, which seems pretty horrible the first time around but becomes much more horrible later, because the first time at least you could think that the chef, who appears to enjoy his job chopping off fishes' heads a little too much, thought he was only killing dumb animals, but later on, having been made aware that the sea creatures are sentient, thinking, feeling beings, the chef still wants to kill Sebastian, so he is just a serial killer. Puts a different spin on that movie, doesn't it?

As I kept thinking about it, I was thinking, too, how water's surface looks that peculiar, awesome way, and that it must be because we are seeing the reflection of only some of the light, because water lets light pass through it, only bending it slightly, but if water passed light through entirely, we wouldn't be able to see it, at all.

That got me thinking -- and this, I imagine, is how scientists like Ben Franklin and Aristotle did 'science' back before you could just google stuff, my being in my swimtrunks in a pool and then walking home being the equivalent of being in the Middle Ages, because while I could have gotten out and checked it out on my phone (Imagine: I carry with me at all time a computer that can answer almost any question! I Love Living In The Future!), I didn't do that, because Mr F was as I said making me play "Up!" which is where I pick him up and almost throw him and then put him back down.  He does not, unlike Mr Bunches, want to be thrown, and his game is much harder than when Mr Bunches asks me to throw him, because I have to lift both up and down for Mr F, so it's a real upper-body workout.

Using my old-fashioned science, I tried to work it out.  If water can be seen, sort of, and air cannot, then that means that light passes entirely through air and only partially through water; it is light beams reflecting off of things that allows us to see them, so if we can see the water in the pool, that means that the light is bouncing off of it.

Which didn't explain why we can't see air, though, as (A) we can, remember, we can see the sky, even if it just seems to be a big blue sheet hanging somewhere up there,and (B) even if air is less densely-packed with molecules or atoms or whatever than water, which was my next hypothesis, that didn't mean that we shouldn't be able to see some air, whenever the photons hit an air molecule near our eyes, for example.  After all, if a dust mote drifts near my eye I can see that, so shouldn't all the little molecules of helium near my eye be visible, too?

Which led to a new hypothesis: maybe it was that there are impurities in the water and that is what we're seeing when we look at water: not the water itself, but the chlorine, or the dust, or... let's not think of any other impurities that could be in water.  Let's leave it at dust and chlorine.  After all, there are supposed to be spots in the ocean that have superclear water where you can see the bottom of the sea 20 feet down, and just because I've never seen them doesn't mean that everyone's lying about them.  (I secretly suspect everyone is lying about them, so I'm going to suspect that you, and you, and even you and all of you over there are liars unless you arrange to send me on an all-expenses-paid factfinding trip-not-vacation to such a place. For two weeks. In January.  Put your money where your mouth is, liars.)

I was doing all this thinking because I still like to exercise my thinking muscle, or 'brain,' before actually looking up the answer, and also because: swimming in a pool.  But that was what I came up with: we are actually seeing impurities in the water, and hence the air, which we see as blue because of impurities?

Didn't seem right, even though that would account for days that are 'hazy,' and fits in with things like when you see smog or fog, too, when the air becomes visible because it has more 'impurities' in it.

Now, then, sitting here this morning with my coffee and my computer and the invisible air all around me, I can check out those answers against 'real' "science", by which I mean the kind of science that even though we generally believe it still does stuff like "makes up dinosaurs that never existed and then pretends they were real," so let's take "real" "science"'s answers with a grain of salt.

First, I googled

Stupid Question #1: Why can't we see air?

I got, with that answer, to a site called "Quora," which is apparently new and which I see on Slate a lot, even though I don't read Slate anywhere near as much  as I used to because Slate honestly is becoming just more and more personal blogs and less and less actual reporting or analysis.  I'd say about 75% of Slate's content is no better or worse than this blog -- things I think about stuff, with some googling thrown in, which is okay if you're writing a blog for fun, but not as okay if you  are purporting to be a serious news source.  It says something when I feel like I get more hard news from HuffPo than from Slate, and that is how I feel.

Anyway, I got to Quora where I had to sign in and create a password to see answers to questions! Oh, good! Another password!  That's awesome!  I love having to constantly have a list of identities with me just to read a #(#%*$ question on the Internet!  I know, you use my email to sell to direct marketers and that's how your website becomes free, I get that's the tradeoff I'm making: I can read your website and you can use my email to have me sent "Groupons" or something, but understanding that, why do I have to have a password? Are we worried that someone will use my email to sign in to Quora as me, passing themselves off as me on a site where they can ask questions about stuff?  That's a fear I can live with.  If the worst thing an identity thief can do with my identity is ask questions in my name, I think I'll survive.

(Side note: given my credit rating, I have a standing offer to identity thieves: If you can qualify for credit using my identity, I'll split the credit with you and not press charges.)

Having signed in and created another junk password that I won't remember so that the next time I use this site 30 months from now I will have to have it "send me a reminder," or something dumb, I got to an answer that I couldn't tell if it was by a scientist or not -- it seemed to be but then again it seemed not to be, which is part of the problem with googling stuff: you never know whose answer you're getting.

In this case, the top answer seemed to be from a guy who billed himself as "not a physicist":



but who still seemed more credible than "Karl Malcolm, scientist, academic, guitarist."



What three things would you want the world to know about you if you were trying to convince them that you were smart? "The ability to play hot guitar licks" is definitely near the top of the list, although people who can do that probably don't advertise it.

The top answers I got from skimming those three entries and then ignoring Karl Malcolm's answer because he said air does not absorb light in the visible spectrum and therefore cannot be seen and even I know that's incorrect, that it is the reflection of light that we see, not the absorption, is that we cannot see air because for the most part, air is too small to interact with light.

(Another problem with the internet? "Science" is not a popularity contest. Having regular folks -- or regular folks with an email address and a willingness to use the phrase "CheezDoodle" as their password -- "vote" on what the "best" answer to a question "is", is not science, or even fact.  The popular answer may or may not be right.  I recall once looking at the question "What flavor are white jellybeans?" The top answer was something like "I don't know, but they are delicious," which, while factually accurate as far as the answerer's own state of mind went, was not really the answer to the question, at least not the way we traditionally think of "answers" as "answers.")

It was actually answerer number 2 on that site that gave me the most insight, as he explained the four ways light interacts with junk:


When light passes through an object, one of four things can happen:
1. Absorption: this occurs when the photons of light interact with the electrons in the material and the photon gives up its energy to the electron. The result is that the electron moves to a higher energy level, and the photon disappears.  This makes objects look opaque. The color of an opaque object is dependent on the range of frequencies that it did not absorb.
2. Reflection: this occurs when the photon gives up its energy to the electron, but another photon of identical energy is emitted.
3. Transmission: the photon doesn't interact with any electron in the material and light exits the material at the same frequency that it came in.
4. Scattering: as Joshua Engel mentions, the light interacts with matter or structures in the matter, being absorbed and re-emitted in a different direction. Earth Science: Why is the sky blue?
Air molecules are sparsely distributed, so light passing through air has a small (but non-zero) chance of interacting with air molecules along its trajectory.  However, if there's a lot of air (imagine a 50-mile stretch), lots of these improbable interactions add up, and the effect of the air molecules becomes visible.  Rayleigh scattering, which is the phenomena causing the sky to be blue, favors light in the blue / violet regions and occurs when interacting molecules are much smaller than the wavelength of light.

That guy goes on to explain that we also 'see' light when there is a temperature differential causing the light to change its path: light goes in a straight line through air but temperature can make it change direction, which is why light appears to shimmer above a hot highway, because the air is hotter just above the tar than it is three feet up, so when the light hits it it changes direction and we see what looks like water above the road.


Which made me think that you could make yourself invisible if you could alter the temperature around your body enough to completely bend the light away -- you would appear as a shimmer, like Predator, maybe, but you would be more or less invisible.

Or would you?

Stupid Question #3 If you could have the air immediately around your body be a superdifferent temperature than the air just past it, would you be invisible?

I'll get to that in a bit.  For now, back to #1:


Stupid Question #1: Why can't we see air?

We can't see air because it's not interacting enough with light: air molecules are (relatively) far apart compared to, say, pizza molecules, which are densely packed (yum!).  That and air molecules are smaller, in many cases, than the light waves/photons (light is a both a wave and not, remember), which means that when light interacts with air, it first has to hit some air, and that's hard to do because air is so small and so far apart (relatively speaking, again.)  When light DOES hit air, because the air molecule is (usually) smaller than the light wave/photon, it undergoes "Rayleigh scattering."


Rayleigh scattering, named after the British physicist Lord Rayleigh,[1] is the elastic scattering of light or other electromagnetic radiation by particles much smaller than the wavelength of the light. The particles may be individual atoms or molecules. It can occur when light travels through transparent solids and liquids, but is most prominently seen in gases. Rayleigh scattering results from the electric polarizability of the particles. The oscillating electric field of a light wave acts on the charges within a particle, causing them to move at the same frequency. The particle therefore becomes a small radiating dipole whose radiation we see as scattered light.

(That's from Wikipedia.)(Quora: your site is less helpful/believable than Wikipedia.)  Rayleigh scattering also has to do with the softness or hardness of the particle.  That's measured by the refractive index:

n= c/v,

where v= the speed of the light through your substance, and c= the speed of light in a vacuum, so that's the same "c" as in E=mc(squared).

Rayleigh scattering is, by the way, why we see the sun as yellow, which

Stupid Question #4 WAIT WHAT I THOUGHT THE SUN WAS YELLOW ALL THE TIME EVEN IF I SAW IT IN SPACE, OR DID SUPERMAN LIE ABOUT THAT TOO?

So we do see air, it's just that we don't see very much of it and the parts we do see are the results of miles and miles of air being piled on top of us (300 miles, total), so we're seeing the results of billions upon billions of extremely rare interactions as the light gets Rayleighed all the way down to us, and by the time the light is near our eyes there's relatively few atoms of air to bounce off of, but if there were lots of them you'd probably see a blue haze around your eyes.

Why blue? That brings us back to

Stupid question #2 Why does the sky reflect all the same uniform shade of blue, instead of slightly different colors because the sky is made up of different atoms or molecules or something of air, and why would nitrogen reflect the same color of blue as oxygen?

 Remember wavelengths of visible light: ROY G BIV or "Richard Of York Gave Battle In Vain," as our British friends like to remember it.  Light goes from very long wavelengths -- 'very' again being relative, okay, everything's relative keep that in mind -- at the red end (650 nanometers) to very short at the blue end (400 nanometers.)

A nanometer is 1/1,000,000,000th of a meter, so you would have to line up 2,500,000 violet light photons in a row to make a yardstick, which I was going to say meterstick but that's dumb, even if it's a meter long we'd still call it a yardstick.

That would be a cool yardstick, though. It would look like a lightsaber.

The important thing to remember here is that how much something Rayleigh scatters is inversely proportional to the fourth power of its wavelength, so the SMALLER the wavelength the larger the scatter, which is why blue and violet light scatter more than red and orange.

Okay, so

Stupid Question #2A why isn't the sky violet then?

Mostly because we breathe oxygen, and partly because of the color of our sun.  Oxygen tends to absorb light near the ultraviolet end, so that reduces the amount of violet we see, and there is more of the kind of light needed to make blue in the spectrum that comes from the sun.  (This caused me to remember when we would burn salts in chemistry to see what spectrum of light they threw off in order to identify them.  I did NOT pass that test.)

Our sun is a 'yellow sun' because of the spectrum of light it gives off. That means that it looks yellowish to us on the Earth, I gather, because if you look at the sun from space, the sun is white.  Also you would be blind, so use sunglasses.

(The sky is of course black in space.)

The sun looks yellow to us because when we look in the direction of the sun (NEVER look directly at the sun although once I did during an eclipse in fourth grade, and I'm still here, so just don't do it for very long) there is less scattering: the rays hit us more directly and we see more of the red and yellow and orange, which is why sunsets aren't blue, either -- it's the way the light is passing through the atmosphere.  At noon, when you look up at the sun (AGAIN NOT FOR TOO LONG) the sunlight comes shooting straight at your retinas from 93,000,000ish miles away and you see most of the spectrum and it evens out to a yellowish-white.  Looked at from the side (i.e., sunset) you see more reds.

As for the rest of question 2, the answer is that the atoms DO refract different colors.  So do larger particles, like smog.

Here is something you didn't know, I bet, and I know I didn't know it: Moonlight is blue, too. Moonlight is just reflected sunlight, but we don't see it as blue because we use rods, not cones, to see at night and rods see only black and white.  If you lived in an area with enough light pollution -- that is, other light to activate your cones -- you'd see the moonlight as blue.  A blue moon is possible all the time!



Then it's on to

Stupid Question #3 If you could have the air immediately around your body be a superdifferent temperature than the air just past it, would you be invisible?

The answer is "yes."  This site explains that carbon nanotubes can conduct heat quickly and efficiently so that a device or cloth made of them would make you invisible.

Or watch this video:



Saturday, July 16, 2011

The Best Stupid Questions About Wizards.



As everyone in the world probably knows, this week saw the opening of the final installment of "Definitely not Willy The Wizard And The Deathly Hallows", a/k/a "Also Definitely Not Larry Potter and The Deathly Hallows" a/k/a "Didn't that scene in the one book where Harry Potter squared off against a giant spider seem awfully familiar"? a/k/a "No, it didn't, you moron, do you want to get sued into the ground"?

Anyway that movie is attracting a lot of attention, and cashing in on other people's hard work is sort of my thing, although sometimes I do it only inadvertently, and in keeping with the way I roll, I'm going to go ahead and jump, with only a little further ado, into this post, with the small amount of further ado (it's just a tiny bit, really, of ado) being to note that so far as I know, nobody has ever written a book in which a wizard just has unlimited powers and absolutely no scruples about using them -- no limits on his power, no qualms or moral objections to using his power, no reason not to just magic up everything in the world...

... with one exception: Disney.

In Disney's Aladdin, remember, Jafar wished to be transformed into a genie, which is more or less like a wizard, too (you'll see I'm expanding the rules in this post) and under the rules of that movie, genies were more or less all-powerful. So Jafar was the first all-powerful wizard with no scruples whatsoever about using his powers, but he had limitations-- because genies, in that movie, are tied to a lamp and must do the bidding of whoever holds the lamp. That was how they trapped him, remember?

(Oh, and, um, SPOILER ALERT!)

But then, at the end of the movie, Aladdin uses his third wish to free the genie, whose name I think was genie, and so at the end of the cartoon Aladdin, Jasmine is the Sultaness, Aladdin is the Sultan-in-waiting, people in Agrabah are happy, and there is an all-powerful being who is definitely not human and maybe not bound at all by our human concepts like "enslaving everyone for fun is wrong".

I never saw Aladdin 2, because by the time that came out our first pack of kids were too old for Disney cartoons, having reached the age where they were more interested in making up bizarre stories about how the dent got into the car, and our backup children, Mr F and Mr Bunches, had not yet arrived.

But I'm sure that in Aladdin 2, either all of humanity is laboring under the oppressive regime of Genie The Almighty, Ruler of All The Cosmos, or the world has been turned into a paradise. Either way, good work, Disney!

Now, on to those Best Stupid Questions About Wizards!

1. What was the genie's name in Aladdin?



At first, when I began to write this post and tried to remember what the genie's name was, I thought "I must have forgotten it," because I'm terrible about names and faces and am about one step away from that guy who mistook his wife for a hat.*

*(Not a paid referral of either the book or hats.)

It seemed to me he must have a name, because genies aren't a person, they're a thing, even by the rules Aladdin set up: Jafar, when he uses his third wish to become a genie, doesn't become Genie, as played by Robin Williams; he becomes a genie.

So is Aladdin's genie just called "Genie"?

He's Genie the genie?

(As an aside, I've now typed the word genie so much that it's lost all meaning to me.)

Other genies have names; in the Aladdin series, I'm told (by a message board filled with people who have way more time than I do, and way less to occupy it) one female genie was named Eden.

So I gather that Aladdin's genie had a name, but nobody bothered to tell us that name.

Or, I gather instead that Aladdin was so shallow that he never bothered to ask genie's name -- even at the end, when he supposedly learned his lesson and stopped being such a jerk fixated only on riches and being someone he was not. Having gotten everything he ever wanted, Aladdin couldn't even be bothered to say, to the person who helped him get it, "Hey, by the way, what's your name?"

Nice.

2. What, exactly, was it that saved Harry Potter's life?



Initially, question 2 was going to be something like why didn't Dumbledore ensure that all students at Hogwarts were taught the spell that protected Harry from the death curse, making it useless and ineffective? I mean, seriously: the Avada Kedavra curse is the wizarding equivalent of hollow-point bullets, and whatever helped Harry is a full-body bullet proof vest, but wizard students spend their time at Hogwarts learning to grow plants?

But then I did some research into the question -- yes, I research stuff, from time to time -- and found that the answer to the question I wanted to ask -- why didn't Dumbledore, etc. etc., -- couldn't be found, because that answer doesn't exist, because...

... nobody really knows how Harry lived.

I thought it was just me, but I'm pretty sure it's just not, and I'm pretty sure that J.K. Rowling, by the end of the seventh book, had more or less forgotten about this and/or decided it was too complicated to explain, and so she explained how Harry lived via this not-at-all-a-deus ex machina:

"It was love. You see, when dear, sweet Lily Potter gave her life for her only son, she provided the ultimate protection. I could not touch him. It was old magic. Something I should have foreseen."
That's Voldemort talking. So, er... love? That's all? Love and giving her life for someone? And Voldemort was aware of all this but never bothered to come up with a counterspell to it?

And old magic? Magic older than all the other magic that took seven books to explain and took years for students to learn? Who, exactly, invented this old magic? Is it still used? Is it centaur magic?

J.K. Rowling never explained -- but the legions of people who desperately want Harry Potter's story to make sense have: they've come up with a whole page of explanation. Basically, they explain, Lily Potter cast a spell of "sacrificial protection." (Where did Lily learn that... never mind.) That's a spell cast by someone who consciously chooses to give their life for another; they must, the page says, be given a chance to save their own life, or someone else's. So Lily can cast the spell because Voldemort promised he wouldn't kill her unless she got in the way -- but then she did, and she chose to give her life to save Harry's.

Later in the books, then, Harry casts the same spell on all his friends -- by turning himself in when Voldemort has demanded that he either do so within the hour or be killed. Harry's turning himself in, rather than fleeing, is the kind of sacrifice that allows him to cast the spell of protection on all his friends at once. (Where did Harry learn that... never mind.)

That poses a problem, though, as Harry's dad, James, also opted to fight rather than flee. So why didn't James' spell protect Harry... and Lily? Apparently (according to the Potterites on that page) you have to be given more than a minute to flee, as James was. Harry's hour of freedom was sufficient time to trigger the ability to cast the spell he never learned and save his friends by having Voldemort cast the death spell on him.

(None of this is explained in the books, mind you. Unless it was when Dumbledore met Harry in that dome thing. I sort of skimmed that part.)

What's also not explained in the books, or on that page, is why Harry's sacrifice works... when Harry himself is not killed? Voldemort's death curse blasts apart the Horcrux in Harry, not killing Harry at all - so Harry has managed to cast a sacrificial protection without, you know, sacrificing anything.

Oh, and, um... SPOILER ALERT?

That all brings up a different question... the question being:

3. Why did Voldemort think he could kill Harry at all?


I'm not going to get into why Voldemort didn't know that his Horcrux was in Harry, or why he didn't know that it would be killed instead of Harry, or why a Horcrux can be killed at all when the whole point is they're not supposed to be killable. Some questions are better left unasked and unanswered, and among them are:

Who would make a "hot" video of James and Lily Potter set to Avril Lavigne's music? Because someone did:



Hmmm.

Anyway, here's a bigger question: So Voldemort knew about the sacrificial protection spell, and it being old magic and all... and he knew that his previous death curse had failed.

What was his plan?

"Shoot him again!" ?

If the sacrificial protection spell is so great that it beats his dead-on curse when Harry's a baby and can't consciously use any magic power at all, why would Voldemort think that years later the same exact curse would work after Harry's been to wizard school? Do sacrificial protection spells wear off? Do they grow weaker over time? If they do, and if Voldemort needed Harry Potter dead to complete his plans, why not wait a few more years, until the protection is completely gone?

And why didn't Voldemort, for that matter, simply get one of his all-too-loyal minions to sacrifice-protection him?

Moving on!

4. Why didn't Gandalf just destroy the bridge before the Balrog was even on it?

For copyright reasons -- and because I'm pretty sure all my resources are going to be tied up defending against J.K. Rowlings' lawyers' claims -- I can't show you the actual Lord of the Rings footage of the epic battle between Gandalf and the Balrog, but here's a pretty decent recreation:




Now, I've always had a problem with the idea that Gandalf has any powers, at all. To recap his "magical" "exploits", he: blew smoke rings and made them change colors; used ventriloquism, rode an eagle, broke a bridge, and resurrected himself (maybe, on that last one; someone else might have done it. We don't know how Gandalf came back.) Granted, that's more impressive than that one brown wizard who could only talk to birds, but it puts Gandalf on a par, magically speaking, with David Copperfield.

Back to the battle: When the Fellowship is running from the Balrog, Gandalf turns and stands on the bridge, telling the Balrog You shall not pass.




And then, the Balrog grabs him and he breaks the bridge and they fall.

From which we can surmise:

1. The Balrog cannot leap or fly.

2. Gandalf can break the bridge.

See where I'm going with this? Gandalf just had to break the bridge before the Balrog got there, and the Fellowship could have gone on -- with his help -- and the Balrog couldn't have gotten them, and then in the future Gandalf and the rest could've gone and fought the Balrog at their leisure.

Maybe it's not that Gandalf didn't have any real magical powers. Maybe he was just too stupid to use them.

5. What about Merlin?

Merlin being the only other wizard I can think of right now, I'll finish up with him, and all I could think to say was the question: What about Merlin?

Which, you'll have to agree, is a pretty stupid question.

Was Merlin the loveable clumsy backwards-living magical guy that showed Wart the way to pull out the Sword in the Stone that Disney wants us to remember?




Or was he this sinister guy who helped Uther Pendragon rape a lady?





That clip is from Excalibur, which I remember as being the coolest swords-and-sorcery movie ever when I was a kid; of course, I ranked it that way for two reasons: (1) the armor was very shiny, and (2) it was on HBO, which meant there was nudity. I never even saw the whole thing, because my parents wouldn't let us watch it, so I'd have to be watching it with the sound way down low late at night when they thought I was watching Don Kirschner's Rock Show.

Merlin began his life as an amalgam of historical figures, including a madman and someone named "Ambrosius Aurelianus" who helped win a battle in the Fifth Century. It's a short hop from that to "being fathered by an incubus," as the Merlin of popular legend was soon said to be, and living backward, as Merlin was also supposed to do:



to being a kid, as the BBC now has it. (Because what's more family friendly than "backward living half-human son of an incubus rape assistant?)




Did Merlin have any real powers? What was he, anyway? For the definitive take on that, I went to Wikipedia, this being the only sort of thing that site is really good for.

Where I learned that things are even worse, or more interesting, or both, than I thought. At one point, Merlin was said to be the antiChrist son of the devil born to a virgin, only to have the plan foiled by the mother, who got the baby baptized (But why couldn't the Devil stop...never mind.) At other times, Merlin is a shapeshifter and a prophet, but also a dumb guy: at one point, Merlin falls in love with a woman and promises to teach her all his magic, unaware that she's going to use the magic to control him, which she then doesn't do, opting instead to imprison him in a tomb for all eternity because she's disgusted by him and his demon heritage.

(Which Merlin somehow did not foresee...never mind.)

Merlin has been featured in, by my count, lots of movies, TV shows, and books. He's met just about everyone in every place.

Which brings us to our final question:

6. Did Merlin ever meet Batman?


Yes. And it was awesome.

Monday, May 30, 2011

The Best Stupid Questions About 80s Songs Used In Commercials.


Rogue Mutt yesterday, reading my post about how the only area of pop culture attuned to my likes is commercials, raised the Philosophical Question: Which song has been featured more in commercials, "Melt With You" or "Tempted" by Squeeze?

Never one to miss an opportunity to take advantage of a chance to eke out a post without having to use my own ideas, and also never one to actually get up and do some real work for a change, I decided to pick up the gauntlet Rogue threw down and find out the answer to his question -- and to raise my own questions, in a post I cleverly titled...

... well, you read the title, didn't you? Let's get on with it.

1. Did Def Leppard really steal a line from The Archies?




There's your Pour Some Sugar On Me, and I sympathize with the guy because I, too, thought they said something about Ramen in there. Here's the full song, sadly minus Catherine Zeta-Jones:




Now for the stupid question's answer: Yes. At the end of The Archies' decidedly non-metal hit Sugar, Sugar, the Archies repeat, over and over, Pour a little sugar on me baby.



They also say "I just can't believe the loveliness of loving you," which is a great line. Admit it. Rolls right off the tongue.

Here's a bigger question, though: What's the deal with 'pouring a little sugar on me?' What's that supposed to mean? The girl the guy is singing about is sugar, right? That's the only way it makes sense. And here's a bigger question: whatever happened to Def Leppard? The answer is: They became Nickelback. It's true: look it up. (Don't look it up.)

2. Why was dancing so dangerous in the 1980s?

Between John Lithgow staring down at Kevin Bacon, that one movie with Sarah Jessica Parker having to sneak out to go to the dance competition, and the dangers of breakdancing, dancing might have ended up as Public Enemy Number One, had not "drugs" and/or "rock lyrics" been seen for the threats they were -- and had not Men Without Hats announced, partway through the decade, that it was safe to dance:





Was that an homage to inception, in the middle of an 80s parody? I don't get it. But that's not the original, of course. Here's the original, featuring the original dwarf, too. :




Was the dwarf an homage to This Is Spinal Tap? Or to that other great threat of the 80s, Dungeons & Dragons?

That song, too, begs another question: What was the Safety Dance? Nobody's really clear. The lead singer of Men Without Hats supposedly said that the song was about New Wave dancers being allowed to dance the way they wanted to, when bouncers would try to stop them from what they viewed as dangerous dancing -- so the song was meant as a big stick in the eye of those counterrevolutionary bouncers.

Hence the nuclear images at the end of the video.

3. Can you get the telephone number 867-5309?




Everyone who was anyone... well, everyone who worked at Chenequa Country Club, and was stuck there late one night but realized that the bar had been left open and so was able to make mixed drinks with their friends in a story that I'll leave hanging because to finish it implies that we then drove home extremely drunk in Bob's white Impala...

... tried dialing that number:



But only a few businesses tried to actually use the number, ending up in court over who had the right to pretend they had once dated Jenny and that's why they use the number, man, to remind me of Jenny, marking the first time ever that plumbing companies became interesting to people when there wasn't poop flowing into their living room.

That lawsuit in turn got Tommy Tutone bothered, because for years he'd claimed it wasn't a real number at all, but if someone's going to get rich off the number, it might as well be him: "It's ridiculous," he said. "If I wanted to get into it, I could probably take the number away from both of them."

But he'd mostly be doing it because he didn't want people thinking he'd spent the 80s pining away for a plumber.

But you don't have to fight Tommy for the right to have people drunk-dial you at night and sing you a song; you could have bought the number yourself on eBay...

... for $365,000.

Imagine how easy it would be to balance the budget without killing senior citizens, if we just taxed stupid eBay auctions.

4. Do extra charges apply if I attach my soul to the text message?

If you were one of the people unlucky enough to be left behind on May 21 -- sure, we all joke about it, but can you swear this isn't the six-months' tribulation? I saw video of Sarah Palin in black leather at the Washington Monument, and if that isn't one of the Seven Signs, I'll eat my hat -- then you might still be able to sneak in the back door of Heaven (the ungated side) by getting a Cingular phone:



That commercial uses Peter Gabriel's Solsbury Hill, a/k/a "That song that wasn't Sledgehammer,":



And
with good reason, too: using a cell phone is pretty much the closest any of us will ever come to a religious experience like the one that inspired Peter Gabriel to right a song about... um... renouncing material things and going to Heaven. The song is explained on SolsburyHill.org thusly:

By February 1977 Peter had passed through a period of relative inactivity, frustrating piano sessions and a slightly bizarre obsession with vegetables notwithstanding (quite understandably, his wife Jill was convinced he had flipped)...

Okay, that doesn't really explain anything, but I did want to quote it here, because anytime I can do a post that ends with the phrase a slightly bizarre obsession with vegetables, I call that a good day's work.

P.S. According to my sources, I Melt With You (which is the actual title) was used in 7 commercials, counting cover versions not done by Modern English. I was only able to find three commercials which used Tempted, and that's counting its use in Grand Theft Auto:



But Tempted was also covered by (I think?) The Waltons:



Whereas I Melt With You was covered by high school girls who play the harp:



So make of that what you will.

Sunday, May 01, 2011

The Four Best Stupid Questions About Disney Cartoons.



As a famous philosopher once said, "Never start out with a quote from someone. It's lazy writing."

That's why I'm going to jump right into this post without the usual foofooraw, a word, which, if you Google it to try to find out whether it's a real word, Google will ask you "Did you mean 'foofaraw,'? as though that is a real word.

Of course, if you click that link and tell Google Yeah, I mean foofaraw, even though you didn't really -- lying to Google is not (yet) a federal offense, you know -- you'll find out that foofaraw is a real word, meaning "a fuss over a trifling matter."

So, in the end, I really did mean foofaraw, even though I first said foofooraw. Thanks, Google!

I have, over the past four years, watched many a Disney cartoon, because the Babies!, who are getting close to five years' old, have watched many a Disney cartoon, too, although my watching Disney cartoons predates Mr F and Mr Bunches' existences; I watched The Little Mermaid when it first came out on video back in the 1990s (and bought the soundtrack, too) and watched The Lion King, too, when that came out because by then I had nephews who watched Disney cartoons, and then I watched Hercules when the older kids watched that (and used Hercules to help get over my irrational fears of the Jeeper Creeper, so I'm kind of an expert when it comes to Disney cartoons, which makes me the perfect person to ask

The Four Best Stupid Questions About Disney Cartoons, the third entry in my series of posts about stupid questions, and we'll begin today's (stupid) introspection with:

1. Why were the Wall-E's needed?

If you've watched Wall*E, then you know that the lovable little robot who [SPOILER ALERT!] saved humanity because he was in love with another lovable little robot had a job to do: he, along with apparently many other Wall*Es, were created to gather up trash and compact it into little squares, which they then used to build monumental trash towers.



Leave aside, for the moment, the question of how that was supposed to help clean up the over-polluted world we humans had created: the Wall*Es were, after all, simply stacking the trash neatly in and around the cities we humans abandoned, not moving it to someplace else. Let's assume that they were doing that in order to, say, launch all the trash into space and lob it into the sun, as a noted genius once said humans should be doing.

If you assume that the Wall*Es were actually doing something useful, the question still remains Why were there Wall*Es at all.

Or EVEs, for that matter.

In the movie, after all, once Eve finds the plant and returns to the spaceship, it turns out that Otto the Autopilot is under orders never to let humans return to Earth.

[OH, UM... SPOILER ALERT? Sorry, I was a little behind on that one. Blame it on my deregulated FAA Air Traffic Controller Training.]

That plan is revealed when the captain of what apparently is the only spaceship full of the only surviving humans tries to get the ship to go back to Earth because plant (and therefore other kinds of life) is now sustainable; but upon trying to execute that order, the captain finds a secret video that tells him that it's all been a ruse, and that there was never any plan to go back to Earth in the first place, because the Buy'N'Large people who set this whole thing up figured that the Earth was beyond redemption and would never be cleaned.

Which, if that was true, doesn't explain why a massive corporation created all the Wall*Es to clean up the place: they were never going to come back, so why bother pretending they're going to clean it up?

Also unexplained: what happened to all the animals on Earth? Not a single animal was seen on the spaceship holding all of humanity, which means either there's another spaceship out there, full of animals (or full of people who learned to love Zebra McNuggets, which is far more likely) or humans returned to Earth to live life as vegetarians.




"So I've just been part of this massive government make-work project...
but I'm only doing that until I finish my screenplay.
What say we go back to my place?"




2. Whatever happened to the OTHER Lost Boys in Pinocchio?

Just
how many chances do you think Pinocchio should have had to prove he can be a good boy? After failing the first time -- going to join a theater company instead of going to school, a choice that paid off handsomely for the Olsen Twins, who are now almost billionaires and are getting richer selling ridiculously overpriced clothing to Mrs. Obama, but for which Pinocchio was punished -- Pinocchio is given a second chance, which he blows even more spectacularly, going to drink and smoke cigars on Pleasure Island.

Which could have made the stupid question "How does a puppet drink or smoke, since he has neither lungs nor a belly?" but I went more profound and philosophical with this one.

Pinocchio narrowly avoids becoming a full-on donkey, you'll recall...



... by coming to his senses just in time and getting off the island, after which [SPOILER ALERT ABOUT A STORY THAT MANY PEOPLE WILL CONFUSE WITH THAT ONE ABOUT JONAH AND THE WHALE, WHICH WILL THEN CAUSE THEM TO THINK OF FOLK-POPSTERS 'NOAH AND THE WHALE', A GROUP THEY REALLY LIKE BUT WHICH HAS BEEN KIND OF REPLACED, ON THEIR PLAYLISTS, BY SLOW CLUB... OR IS THAT JUST ME]

Pinocchio and Jiminy run into Geppetto, who has been swallowed by a whale, and they save him, after which Glinda The Good Witch (I'm pretty sure that was her) makes Pinocchio a real boy... because why? What did he do that was so good? Run away to stop becoming a donkey? Wasn't that why he left the island?

(I've just looked it up and realized that he set off to save Geppetto and sacrificed his life to do so, which means that Pinocchio effectively co-opted pretty much all of the Biblical heroes into his story, a fact I'm only pointing out to get you to overlook that I was wrong about whether he was a good boy or not.)

So Pinocchio is a real boy and dances to celebrate with Geppetto and everyone's happy, except that Pinocchio never seems to tell Geppetto about the magical slave ring that's going on.

Sure, maybe that took place offscreen - -maybe, after the movie ended and Pinnochio settled into life as a real boy, he said over dinner one day "Hey, Father, by the way, did you know that men are kidnapping bad little boys, turning them into donkeys and selling them into slavery?"

But I don't think so -- because wouldn't that be pretty much the first thing you said when you woke up as a real boy?

Assuming you're a good real boy, that is: wouldn't you say "Hey, great, I'm a real boy, and now I can help do something to help all those other kids."

But, no, Pinocchio just seems to go on about his life, never bothering to wonder what happened to Lampwick and the rest.





"Oh, yeah. Those guys.
Well, maybe they
like being donkeys, right?"



3. Where were the super-villains in "The Incredibles?"

The whole plot of The Incredibles revolves around the idea that Americans -- I'm assuming it's America, because the insurance industry makes its money screwing people over and the government claims to be out of money -- would reject superheroes who want to help them and engage in a variety of frivolous lawsuits making outrageous claims about people whose only purpose in life was to protect them.

That would never happen, right?

Right...

Anyway, after the trial lawyers got hold of super hero claims -- and somehow forced the government to pay for damages caused by the heroes, who must have had some government affiliation to cause that, right? -- the super heroes went into hiding and the government passed a law mandating that no superhero lawsuits could be filed anymore.

Which is great... except that it left a bunch of supervillains running around, in a world where the police needed help to catch a bank robber.

Now, granted, the movie was pretty short on naming the villains-- there was Bomb Voyage, and that Mole Guy at the end, The Underminer, and other than them, and Syndrome, who wouldn't have been a villain if Mr. Incredible hadn't been such an incredible jerk (see what I did there?) But there were other problems -- including the guy with the missile in this clip:



So if there were other supervillains, what happened to them? Did the police suddenly become much more effective? Did Syndrome kill them off? Did they go into hiding, too?


It's easy to be a superhero
when the only people you fight are
skinny muggers.


4. Why did Buzz Lightyear stop talking when Andy came into the room?

The original Toy Story movie is generally lauded as the single greatest human achievement ever, judging by the hyperbolic way people rhapsodize about it.

Don't get me wrong: I loved it as much as the next guy, and, like the next guy, I tried to blame my tears, at the part of Toy Story 3 where the toys are going to be incinerated, on dust in the theater.

But Toy Story had a major gaping plot hole: If Buzz Lightyear didn't know he was a toy, why did he stop moving when Andy was around?

As I gathered, the rules of being a toy are that you're not supposed to move around people. Woody says as much, at the end, when they're all going to rescue Buzz from Sid: "We'll have to break some rules," Woody tells them.

(That, by the way, is supposed to be kind of a dramatic moment: Woody is advising toys to break the rules. But that's about the least disturbing thing Woody -- who I've pointed out previously wasn't the nice guy everyone thinks -- does. Woody, remember, knocked Buzz out a window and then lied about it.)

Woody's plan then goes on to break those rules, proving that toys, when they want to, can move around in the presence of people. They just choose not to.

Which means that Buzz, at the beginning of the movie, can move around even when Andy's around. So why doesn't he? Buzz, after all, doesn't think he's a toy -- most of the plot of the first movie revolves around Woody's efforts to get Buzz to realize his place in the world (and, not incidentally, to realize Woody's place in that world.)

If Buzz doesn't think he's a toy, why does he act like a toy?

Toy Story 2 explained part of this by pointing out that all Space Rangers are to be in "hypersleep" until they're purchased -- which is why America wasn't terrorized by legions of tiny men struggling against their plastic bonds at Toys'R'Us stores -- but nobody ever explained why Buzz, once freed from "hypersleep" at Andy's birthday party didn't immediately start moving around, and enlist Andy and his other giant friends in an effort to help him take on Zurg.



"I'm telling you, Sheriff, these people are HUGE, and
I'm going to enlist them to help me fight. Heck, with
just a few of them, I can quit being a low-paid Space Ranger
and set myself up as Emperor. If you thought a clone army was
tough to beat..."*